P 97 Personality and the Practice of Ministry

Further Resources

Return to: Pastoral series

Statistical Tables

The accompanying Grove Pastoral booklet has been written as far as possible to make sense to readers who are unfamiliar with the technical vocabulary and statistical notations of a quantitative approach to personality psychology and empirical theology. At the same time, enough statistical detail has been given below to allow the argument to be properly assessed and evaluated by those with a professional interest in psychology. It may be helpful, therefore, to explain how to read the scientific notation.

Two statistical tests of association are employed in this booklet. In chapter 3, analysis of variance (F) is used to test whether there is a significant difference between mean scores recorded by different groups. Elsewhere the Pearson correlation coefficient (r) is used to test the association between two variables. In understanding the meaning of both of these statistics the notion of probability is important. We are looking for relationships which are unlikely to have occurred by mere chance. The five percent level of probability (.05) says that the association could have occurred five times in a hundred by chance; the one present level of probability (.01) says that the association could have occurred only once in a hundred times by chance; the point one percent level of probability (.001) says that the association could have occurred only once in a thousand times by chance. The lower the chance probability, the more confidence we can place in the findings. When there is no significance in the reported statistics this is indicated by the convention NS (not significant).

 

Table 3.1 Extraversion scores by denomination

denomination mean sd N
Anglican 7.02 3.63 194
Baptist 7.03 3.63 291
Free Evangelical 7.58 3.34 84
Pentecostal 7.63 3.57 104
New Church 8.19 3.43 187

F = 3.78, P<.01

 

Table 3.2 Neuroticism scores by denomination

denomination mean sd N
Pentecostal 3.25 2.94 104
Free Evangelical 3.31 2.65 84
New Church 3.39 3.25 187
Anglican 4.00 3.10 194
Baptist 4.15 3.24 291

F = 3.23, P<.01

 

Table 3.3 Psychoticism scores by denomination

denomination mean sd N
Free Evangelical 2.33 1.90 84
Baptist 2.38 1.93 291
Pentecostal 2.44  2.15 104
New Church 2.56 1.97 187
Anglican 2.87 2.28 194

F = 1.94, NS

 

Table 3.4 Personality and frequency of glossolalia

personality dimension r P<
extraversion +0.15 .001
neuroticism -0.10 .001
psychoticism -0.04 NS

 

Table 4.1 Personality and size of membership

personality dimension r P<
extraversion +0.11 .001
neuroticism -0.12 .001
psychoticism -0.03 NS

 

Table 4.2 Personality and proportion of male members

personality dimension r P<
extraversion +0.09 .01
neuroticism -0.06 NS
psychoticism -0.01 NS

 

Table 4.3 Induction strategies emphasised by high E pastors

strategies r P<
follow-up visit and telephone calls +0.14 .001
induction to church life +0.14 .001
link with another church member +0.12 .001
placed in home group +0.12 .001
introductory literature +0.09 .01

 

Table 5.1 Role priorities emphasised by high E pastors

ministry role r P<
pioneer +0.27 .001
leader in the local community +0.18 .001
evangelist +0.18 .001
apostle +0.17 .001
prophet +0.12 .001
spiritual director +0.11 .001
fund-raiser +0.11 .001
fellowship-builder +0.11 .001
social worker +0.08 .01

 

Table 5.2 Role priorities emphasised by high N pastors

ministry role r P<
minister of sacraments +0.11 .001
theologian +0.08 .01
leader of public worship +0.08 .01

 

Table 5.3 Role priorities emphasised by high P pastors

ministry role r P<
pioneer +0.11 .001
apostle +0.09 .01
evangelist +0.09 .01

 

Table 5.4 Role priorities emphasised by low P pastors

ministry role r P<
pastor -0.14 .001
visitor -0.13 .001
fellowship-builder -0.10 .01
teacher -0.09 .01

 

Table 5.5 Proportion of pastoral care emphasised by high E pastors

groups r P<
elders +0.17 .001
counsellors +0.15 .001
house group leaders +0.12 .001

 

Table 5.6 Proportion of pastoral care emphasised by high N pastors

groups r P<
elders -0.14 .001
house group leaders -0.13 .001
members of the congregation -0.11 .001
counsellors -0.09 .01

 

Table 6.1 Personality and physical health

personality dimension r P<
extraversion +.08 .01
neuroticism -.21 001
psychoticism -.01 NS

 

Table 6.2 Personality and mental health

personality dimension r P<
extraversion +0.13 .001
neuroticism -0.34 .001
psychoticism +0.03 NS

 

Table 6.3 Personality and spiritual health

personality dimension r P<
extraversion +0.17 .001
neuroticism -0.22 .001
psychoticism +0.06 NS

 

Table 6.4 Personality and thoughts of leaving ministry

personality dimension r P<
extraversion -0.03 NS
neuroticism +0.28 .001
psychoticism -0.01 NS

 

Table 6.5 Personality and exhaustion

personality dimension r P<
extraversion -0.03 NS
neuroticism +0.26 .001
psychoticism -0.01 NS

 

Table 6.6 Personality and in-service training

personality dimension r P<
extraversion +0.16 .001
neuroticism -0.09  .01
psychoticism -0.08 .01

Return to top

Return to: Pastoral series